I Want to Smash the Compliance Paradigm

compliance-based-parenting

Fair warning: this is a bit of a rant.

I am tired of the assumption that the goal of parenting is to get children to do what adults say.

Quickly. Pleasantly. Preferably without asking too many questions or making an inconvenient face.

We dress it up in nicer language. We talk about “good choices” and “appropriate behavior.” But underneath, the question is often the same:  How do I get this kid to comply?

I want us to ask a different question. I want to smash the whole paradigm. Because I don’t think the children are the problem. I think our culture of compliance has a lot to answer for.

Whose comfort are we protecting?

When a child won’t participate, won’t wear the clothes, won’t hug the relative, won’t sit still, or won’t stop asking why, we tend to focus on changing the child. And sometimes there’s a real need involved. We have to leave. Someone needs quiet. Bodies need to be safe.

But sometimes the need is for an adult to feel obeyed, and I think we owe children enough honesty to notice the difference.

A child’s discomfort doesn’t become less important because accommodating it would inconvenience us. An adult’s preference doesn’t automatically become a moral obligation because we put “please” in front of it. And also, in case you’re wondering: an adult’s preference isn’t automatically more important than a child’s just because we’re bigger.

I don’t want to teach children that being good means becoming easy for other people to manage.

I want kids to know themselves. To recognize when something feels wrong. To ask questions. To have access to their own no. Even when their “no” complicates my afternoon.

What if they’re showing us something?

Some children make the flaws in our systems very difficult to ignore.

The room is too loud. The schedule leaves no time to recover. The clothing hurts. The expectation makes no sense. Everyone is supposed to learn, communicate, move, and participate in the same way.

And when a child can’t make themselves fit, we create a plan to improve their behavior.

I want us to spend more time examining what they’re being asked to fit into.

I see children calling attention to conditions that other people have learned to tolerate, hide their reactions to, or endure at considerable personal cost. They may not deliver that information politely. They may deliver it by lying under a table. Or scratching the person who was trying to make them do a Thing.

I would still like us to consider the information.

A system that only works when people suppress their needs, differences, and honest responses needs to change.

Yes, we have to coexist

Of course we do.

Your child doesn’t get to hurt someone because they’re expressing their truest self. Other people have bodies, needs, preferences, and limits, too.

But the road to coexistence cannot depend on one person’s surrender to another person’s rules.

I want children to learn how to live alongside other people: how to communicate a need, hear someone else’s, handle a limit, make a repair, and work toward a solution.

That takes practice. It takes support. And it takes adults who are willing to do those things themselves.

We have more power. We also have more responsibility for how we use it.

Sometimes I will make a decision a child dislikes. Sometimes safety requires immediate action. I can do that without making obedience the measure of their character.

What I want instead

Here are two places I want us to start.

Before enforcing a rule, ask what it protects. Is it protecting someone’s safety, access, rest, or belongings? Or is it protecting a custom / rule / routine / belief that we haven’t questioned?

When a child resists, get curious before deciding what the resistance means. What are they experiencing? What would make participation possible? Is there another way to meet the actual need?

I know. This takes longer. So does spending years fighting over expectations that were never a good fit.

I want a world where children can belong without having to disappear into someone else’s idea of acceptable. Where adults can hold limits without humiliation or frustration. Where difference gives us something to work with.

If that’s idealistic, I’m ok with that. Thank you for stopping by my soapbox. 

xo G

PS - If you want help making this work in the wonderfully inconvenient reality of your family, schedule a 1:1 parent coaching session with me.

Next
Next

Your Child’s Development Didn’t Get Your Calendar Invite